Comparative Analysis between the Truth and Reconciliation of South Africa and the Reconciliation Commission of Ethiopia
No Thumbnail Available
Date
2025-06-01
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Addis Abeba Universty
Abstract
This study provides a comparative analysis of post-conflict reconciliation in South Africa (focusing on the TRC, 1995–2002) and Ethiopia (specifically the post-EPRDF efforts, 2018–present). The research aims to: examine the historical roots of conflicts in both nations; assess the similarities and differences between their reconciliation approaches; analyze the effectiveness of each model in addressing justice, accountability, and social cohesion; and identify key lessons from South Africa’s TRC that could enhance Ethiopia’s ongoing peace building initiatives. The study compares their conflict histories and reconciliation frameworks, assessing their impacts on justice and unity, and suggests actionable insights for Ethiopia's recovery. Methodologically, the study relies on a secondary data approach, utilizing TRC reports, academic literature, and policy analyses for both countries. Thematic and comparative analyses are employed to evaluate truth-telling, accountability structures, victim reparations, and institutional reforms. Key findings indicate that South Africa’s TRC, with its emphasis on public hearings, conditional amnesty, and restorative justice, fostered national healing but struggled significantly with the issue of incomplete economic reparations. The study highlights the crucial importance of a victim-centered justice approach, transparent public engagement, and systemic reforms in reconciliation efforts. The study concludes that while South Africa’s TRC offers a valuable framework for truth-seeking and reconciliation, Ethiopia must adapt these lessons to its complex ethno-political context. Recommendations for Ethiopia include: establishing an independent truth commission; striking a balance between amnesty and accountability; implementing structured reparations; and integrating traditional conflict-resolution mechanisms. Ultimately, sustainable peace in Ethiopia requires a tailored approach that addresses historical grievances while fostering inclusive governance and promoting long-term social cohesion
Description
Keywords
Comparative Analysis, Truth and Reconciliation of South Africa and, The Reconciliation Commission of Ethiopia