Post-1994 Instructional Reforms in Primary schools in Ethiopia (1994-2024/25): Analyzing school-Based professional Learning From change and organizational Learning Perspectives.
No Thumbnail Available
Date
2025-04-10
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Addis ababa University
Abstract
Organizations, including schools, can transform into learning organizations (Can, 2010; Knapp,
2008; Senge et al., 2012; Kools & Stoll, 2017). In educational settings, organizational learning
(OL) manifests through cognitive and behavioral shifts among learning entities—personal, team,
and organizational agencies—in pursuit of institutional goals (Hora & Hunter, 2013). This study
investigates the learning of post-1994 instructional reforms (e.g., active learning, continuous
assessment, action research, reflective practice) in primary and middle schools through a
sequential explanatory mixed-methods design integrating change and organizational learning
theories. Accordingly, phase-1 conducted a systematic literature review of reform endorsement
processes; phase-2 surveyed 48 randomly selected schools in the Amhara regional state (N=785
teachers, F=390) to quantify learning organization attributes; Phase-3 performed qualitative
case studies of two contrasting schools (N=12 participants) via interviews and document reviews.
Key findings reveal: (1) reforms were persistently top-down, excluding grassroots
practitioners—a tradition entrenched across the last eight decades of Ethiopian education
reform; (2) Level-III schools demonstrated stronger learning organization constructs and
characteristics than Level-II schools; (3) Level-III schools, which benefited from good
leadership, actively and innovatively applied government-prescribed organizational learning
mechanisms; (4) servant leadership optimized government-endorsed OL mechanisms; and (5)
leadership emerged as the paramount factor enabling or constraining OL. The study also
identified organizational learning disabilities (reform fatigue, institutional amnesia, selfcensorship,
Golem effect), particularly in poorly led schools. Grounded in these findings, three
entrenched assumptions are challenged: (i) leadership quality (more than teacher quality)
determines reform success in top-down reform contexts; (ii) assessment mandates (not
pedagogical inheritance) shape teaching practices; (iii) learning capacity (not entry
achievement) influences teacher engagement with reforms. The study concludes that Ethiopia’s
top-down reform tradition fundamentally inhibits meaningful OL, perpetuating cyclical failure,
and recommends participatory reform frameworks to disrupt this pattern, alongside future
research directions.
Description
Keywords
Educational change, Ethiopia, instructional reforms, organizational learning, school leadership