Browsing by Author "Edlawit Teka"

Now showing 1 - 1 of 1
  • No Thumbnail Available
    Item
    A Study on Improving Project Delivery Method Selection Criteria Practice on Ethiopian Road Authority
    (Addis Ababa University, 2020-09-01) Edlawit Teka; Wubishet Jekale (PhD)
    Construction industry in Ethiopia is one of the fast growing industries with significant share in the GDP. It has an important contribution to the economy which involves various infrastructure developments. One of the major infrastructure elements is the road sector. Ethiopian Road authority has a long history in providing road infrastructure primarily in the country. A project delivery method (PDM) is a framework that determines the relationship and responsibilities of client, contractor and consultant. The decision to select delivery method should be based on a systematic approach that includes all available PDMs. The project under the Ethiopian Roads Authority ERA, continue to face great challenges when it comes to delivering projects by selecting the most appropriate DM for its projects. The general practice in this institution is largely depends on culture of the ERA board’ reliance on their familiarity and experience with a particular method. With this background, this study provides a comprehensive solution for this challenges of ERA. 27 criterions under four group of delivery method selection criteria are identified in this research effort. The criteria are identified through questionnaire survey from client, consultant and contractor perspectives. The result is analysed using Relative Importance Index(RII). Project actual challenges are thoroughly discussed based on 22 selected case study projects that are completed under RSDP IV and RSDP V. The analysis clarifies main challenges of ERA’s projects. The major challenges identified are: Right of way, variation orders, scope change, design change and adverse weather conditions. A sufficient set of critical issues are defined in this study and advantages/disadvantages of each delivery method is thoroughly studied with respect to the issues concentrating on the effects of PDM option on the project challenges. The study covers both the available PDMs (i.e. Design-Bid-Build (DBB), Design Build (DB). The model for selecting appropriate delivery method is developed using Multi-attribute decision tools to select a PDM in this research for case study projects. The model was verified using case study project. The model provides useful information and introduces the advantages and limitations of each PDM to the decision makers. an essential well-structured decision making process is embedded in the proposed framework of this study as a result of the analysis that is reliable and sufficient to solve the problem of selecting an appropriate PDM. Key word: - Delivery method selection criteria, project challenges, Multi Attribute Utility Theory